Here's the honest truth:
It definitely did leave my lashes plumper and thicker without major clumping. On the flip side, it irritated my eyes sometimes if I left it on all day. I liked that it didn't smear much, but I also can't say that it never smeared. By the end of the night I'd have definite dark smudges under my eyes that much cheaper brands didn't leave.The truth is, I do like it. I like it a lot. If it were a $15 tube of mascara, I would be hooked. But to pay $35 for this tube?
Pass.
I received these products complimentary from Influenster for testing purposes.